The Week That Was: 2021-02-20 (February 20, 2021)
Dropped at You by SEPP (www.SEPP.org)
The Science and Environmental Coverage Venture
Quote of the Week: “Studies that say that one thing hasn’t occurred are at all times attention-grabbing to me, as a result of as we all know, there are recognized knowns; there are issues we all know we all know. We additionally know there are recognized unknowns; that’s to say we all know there are some issues we have no idea. However there are additionally unknown unknowns—those we don’t know we don’t know. And if one appears all through the historical past of our nation and different free international locations, it’s the latter class that tends to be the tough ones.” – Secretary of Protection Donald Rumsfeld, Feb 12, 2002
Variety of the Week: – 70% undependable.
THIS WEEK:
By Ken Haapala, President, Science and Environmental Coverage Venture (SEPP)
Promote the Delusion: The extreme chilly that hit Texas this week gave recent alternatives for many who have interaction in finger pointing and those that promote myths regarding local weather change and methods to deal with it. There isn’t a bodily proof that rising CO2 within the environment from say 300 elements per million to 400 elements per million, zero.01% of the molecules within the environment, will trigger cooling. (Equally, there may be little bodily proof that it’s going to trigger harmful warming, although that has develop into a preferred political delusion.)
When California skilled blackouts this summer season, many politicians ignored the truth that in California the legislature is chargeable for all utilities. As an alternative, they promptly blamed the utilities and world warming for failure of utilities to supply wanted electrical energy. Thereby they tried to deflect their very own obligations.
grid is an energized system of electrical energy turbines, transformers, transmission and distribution traces and shoppers that have to be maintained inside tight tolerances. In any other case, it fails for all. For years, the California Impartial Methods Operator (CAISO), which is chargeable for sustaining the grid in main elements of California, has been warning the general public that elevated photo voltaic technology, normally within the type of photoelectric panels, will place an awesome burden on electrical technology because the solar goes down.
CAISO developed the CAISO Duck Curve, illustrating that rising photo voltaic and erratic wind energy can produce oversupply energy when not wanted and lack energy when it’s wanted essentially the most. When the latter happens, the grid operator should shut off energy to a part of the grid to stop failure for all shoppers. For years, California politicians have ignored the proof that unusually heat, nonetheless climate would create conditions the place CAISO should shut off energy to elements of the grid to guard the grid from main injury lasting months, which, after all, create blackouts that vex shoppers..
When such conditions resulted in California Blackouts final yr, the politicians blamed everybody else – and local weather change – to cover their very own duty. Sadly, this can be a frequent instance of actions by many politicians and bureaucrats: When proof contradicts the political delusion; promote the parable, ignore the proof. We’re seeing the identical in Texas. See http://www.caiso.com/Paperwork/Flexibleresourceshelprenewables_FastFacts.pdf
*******************
Ignore the Proof: Though others expressed related views, within the quote of the week Donald Rumsfeld succinctly expressed the problem in finding out that which we all know and that which we have no idea, in addition to ranges of ignorance. For his effort, he was ridiculed within the common press. It’s helpful to use Rumsfeld’s reasoning to attempt to perceive what occurred in Texas this previous week.
The plains states, together with Texas, are topic to extreme outbreaks of chilly winter climate in addition to extreme outbreaks of scorching climate. Within the 19th century, settlers within the higher Midwest famous extreme blasts of chilly Arctic air. Within the 1880s, even Theodore Roosevelt speculated whether or not the Nice Plains have been inhabitable. Throughout such occasions, cattle froze as far south as Texas, and the well-known schoolchildren’s blizzard of 1888 killed over 200 kids who misplaced their manner going house from college. Blaming the chilly outbreak in Texas on a change within the slight quantity of CO2 within the environment is absurd. Some climate forecasting organizations resembling WeatherBell Analytics predicted the outbreak of chilly, others didn’t. The outbreak was neither unpredictable nor unprecedented. The query is what do we all know presently?
Thankfully, the grid operator for 90% of Texas is ERCOT, which posts glorious helpful data. As with different US grid operators, ERCOT tries to be 99.9% dependable. There was a extreme chilly outbreak in 2011 and in 2014. How has ERCOT responded to extreme chilly outbreaks?
In 2021, its technology by gasoline from Gasoline Mixed Cycle was 35%, Wind 25%, Coal 22% Nuclear 12%, Gasoline three% and Photo voltaic 2%. The abstract for month-to-month technology will not be but accessible. In 2020 its technology by gasoline was Gasoline-Mixed Cycle 40%, Wind 23%, Coal 18%, Nuclear 11%, Gasoline 6%, Photo voltaic 2%. The months for best technology was July and August, the best wind technology was December.
For 2020, about 25 p.c of technology was from weather-dependent photo voltaic and wind; in 2021, 27%. Within the current chilly outbreak, inland wind generators froze and photo voltaic was snow lined, ineffective. Nonetheless, shoreline wind manufacturing was maintained (the floor water temperature at Galveston was over 55 levels F (over 15 levels C). From excessive chilly within the winter to excessive nonetheless, warmth in the summertime, about 25% of the electrical energy generated for ERCOT is from intermittent, undependable sources. In accordance with studies, ERCOT assumes that within the winter solely 10% of its technology may be counted on to come back reliably from wind. The truth that so many wind installations have been constructed is a results of big-money politics, not practicality. See hyperlinks underneath Difficult the Orthodoxy, Questioning the Orthodoxy, Subsidies and Mandates Without end, https://www.kansas.com/information/native/news-columns-blogs/the-story-of-kansas/article1105618.html and http://www.ercot.com/gridinfo/technology
*******************
Two Markets: One of the helpful analyses regarding Texas Blackouts was by “Planning Engineer” writing in Judith Curry’s “Local weather And so on.” He writes:
“The story from some media sources is that frozen wind generators are chargeable for the ability shortfalls in Texas. Different media sources emphasize that fossil gasoline assets ought to shoulder the blame as a result of they’ve giant chilly induced outages as properly and likewise some pure gasoline vegetation couldn’t get hold of gasoline.
“Excessive chilly ought to be anticipated to trigger vital outages of each renewable and fossil fuel-based assets. Why would anybody anticipate that ample quantities of pure gasoline can be accessible and deliverable to provide a lot wanted technology? Contemplating the intense chilly, nothing significantly shocking is occurring inside any useful resource class in Texas. The applied sciences and their efficiency have been properly throughout the anticipated bounds of what may have been foreseen for such climate circumstances. Whereas some degradation ought to be anticipated, what is occurring in Texas is a departure from what they need to be experiencing. Who or what then is chargeable for the surprising penalties produced by Texas’s run-in with this current bout of maximum chilly?”
“TRADITIONAL PLANNING
“Historically, duty for guaranteeing satisfactory capability throughout excessive circumstances has fallen upon particular person utility suppliers. A pair a long time in the past I used to be chargeable for the load forecasting, transmission planning and technology planning efforts of an electrical cooperative within the southeastern US. My group’s projections, research and evaluation supported our plans to fulfill buyer demand underneath forecasted peak load circumstances. We had seen appreciable progress in residential and business warmth pumps. At colder temperature, these models cease producing warmth effectively and change to resistance heating which [requires substantially increased power and therefore] causes a spike in demand. Our forecasts confirmed that we would want to plan for further capability to fulfill this potential demand underneath excessive circumstances in upcoming winters.
“I used to be raked over the coals and this forecast was strongly challenged. Offering further technology capability, guaranteeing dedicated (agency) deliveries of gasoline through the winter, upgrading transmission amenities are all costly endeavors. Premiums are paid to make sure gasoline supply and backup energy and there’s no refund if it’s not used. Such actions elevated the annual funds and impression charges considerably for one thing that isn’t prone to happen most years, even when the intense climate projections are acceptable. You definitely don’t wish to over-estimate peak demand as a result of rising prices related to assembly that demand. However again then we have been obligated to supply for such “anticipated” hundreds. Our CEO, accountants and charge makers would ideally have preferred a decrease excessive demand projection as that may typically stored our price down. It was difficult to carry agency and stand by the research and pressure the additional prices on our Members.”
Right here we see the true battle: does one plan for what is predicted or for the bizarre? Planning engineer goes on to clarify:
“The Method in Texas
“Who’s chargeable for offering satisfactory capability in Texas throughout excessive circumstances? The quick reply is nobody. The Electrical Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) appears at potential forecasted peak circumstances and anticipated accessible technology and if there may be ample margin, they assume every little thing will likely be all proper. However in contrast to utilities underneath conventional fashions, they don’t be certain that the assets can ship energy underneath hostile circumstances, they don’t require that turbines have secured agency gasoline provides, they usually don’t be sure that the assets will likely be prepared and accessible to function. They depend on sufficient assets being there as a result of they assume that’s of their proprietor’s finest pursuits. In contrast to all different US power markets, Texas doesn’t also have a capability market. By design they rely solely upon the power market. Because of this entities revenue solely from the precise power they promote into the system. They don’t see any revenue from having stand by capability prepared to assist out in emergencies. The power solely market works properly underneath regular circumstances to maintain costs down. Whereas usually markets are sometimes nice issues, offering wanted power throughout excessive circumstances evidently will not be their forte. In contrast to the normal strategy the place particular entities have obligations to fulfill peak ranges, in Texas the duty is diffuse and unassigned. There isn’t a vital long-term motivation for entities to make sure further capability simply in case it could be wanted throughout excessive circumstances. Entities that may make that gamble theoretically can revenue when markets skyrocket, however such approaches require super persistence and the flexibility to climate a few years of potential destructive returns.”
The underside line is that in Texas, nobody is formally chargeable for offering satisfactory electrical energy underneath excessive circumstances. Nonetheless, clearly in the end the legislature have to be accountable. Will it ignore the proof that its insurance policies, or non-policies, lead to blackouts as occurred in California? We will see. Planning Engineer concludes with:
“Anybody can take a look at Texas and observe that fossil gasoline assets may have carried out higher in the chilly. If those that owned the vegetation had secured assured gasoline, Texas would have been higher off. Extra emergency peaking models can be an awesome factor to have available. Why would turbines be inclined to do such a factor? Think about, what can be occurring if the house owners of gasoline technology had constructed ample technology to get by this emergency with some extra energy? As an alternative of amassing $9,00zero per MWH from present functioning models, they might be receiving lower than $100 per MWH for the output of these vegetation and their new vegetation. Why would anybody make super infrastructure that may sit idle in regular years and serve to slash your income by orders of magnitudes in excessive circumstances?
“The inducement for gasoline technology to do the precise factor was taken away by Texas’s deliberate power solely market technique. The aim of which was to assist the profitability of intermittent wind and photo voltaic assets and improve their penetration ranges. I don’t consider anybody has ever superior the notion that fossil gasoline vegetation would possibly function primarily based on altruism. Incentives and duty have to be paired. Doing a autopsy on the Texas scenario ignoring incentives and duty is inappropriate and incomplete.”
Texas is self-sufficient in oil and pure gasoline; it exports it nationally and internationally. Some wells produce water in addition to pure gasoline and the water froze through the deep chilly. However there are ample depleted wells to retailer a month’s provide of pure gasoline to fulfill any doable contingency and, as seen in northern states, pipelines may be winterized. Equally, coal may be saved on website. Some coal and nuclear vegetation could have been present process upkeep, however TWTW discovered no verification that the cooling intakes have been frozen placing them out of fee.
Texas is attracting excessive tech industries together with chip producers which require dependable electrical energy. A brief interruption can destroy weeks of manufacturing. In contrast to their colleagues in California, will the legislators in Texas present the mandatory incentives to guarantee dependable electrical energy? See hyperlinks underneath Looking for a Widespread Floor, Vitality Points – Texas, Various, Inexperienced (“Clear”) Photo voltaic and Wind, and https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electrical energy/electricity-in-the-us.php
*******************
Blackouts Coming Close to You? The above centered on blackouts in Texas and to a lesser extent California. It’s too early to inform if the Biden administration will observe by in its assertions to cease carbon dioxide emissions. In accordance with the US Vitality Data Company (EIA), in 2019 coal and pure gasoline generated 61% of US electrical energy, nuclear 20%, wind 7.three%, hydro 6.6%, photo voltaic 1.Eight%, biomass 1.four%, and petroleum 1%. Changing fossil fuels with wind and photo voltaic will make 70% of US electrical energy topic to surprising blackouts.
Nationwide insurance policies apart, Donn Dears has a superb rationalization and a video how varied US grid system operators favor unreliable photo voltaic and wind over dependable turbines of electrical energy. Bluntly, a lot of the American public is paying greater than wanted for electrical energy underneath the pretense that the public sale system getting used is offering the bottom value doable. See hyperlinks underneath Questioning the Orthodoxy and https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electrical energy/electricity-in-the-us.php
*******************
Faux Proof, Faux Science: UK’s Paul Homewood supplies a transparent video by Ben Pile of “Spiked” explaining one of many methods being utilized by world warming advocates. They use fashions to supply estimates of what fashions calculate could occur with a rise in CO2, then evaluate these estimates to estimates from the fashions of what could occur with out the rise in CO2. That is laptop simulation vs. laptop simulation, slightly than simulation vs. actuality, which it ought to be. The worldwide local weather fashions vastly overestimate the precise warming of the environment over the previous 40 years. The modelers know this and have gotten determined. No surprise Ben Pile is so closely attacked for clearly figuring out and explaining these methods. See hyperlinks underneath Difficult the Orthodoxy.
*******************
Variety of the Week: – 70% undependable. As said above, utilizing EIA numbers, if the Biden administration succeeds in changing coal and pure gas-powered electrical energy technology to photo voltaic and wind, then it might make about 70% of US electrical energy technology undependable (non-dispatchable). The general public wouldn’t be capable of depend on it when wanted. As Donald Rumsfeld would possibly say, recognized unknowns are dangerous sufficient, however changing a recognized with an unknown unknown is folly. See hyperlinks underneath Change in US Administrations.
NEWS YOU CAN USE:
Censorship
Fb now ‘arbiter of fact’ on ‘local weather change’
Panel with Yale, Cambridge specialists to debunk ‘myths’ of ‘deniers’
By Artwork Moore, WND, Feb 18, 2021 [H/t Bernie Kepshire]
“The specialists will come from the likes of the College of Cambridge, George Mason College and the Yale Program on Local weather Change Communication.”
[SEPP Comment: The promoters of the false 97% consensus at George Mason are in charge of fighting misinformation?]
YouTube Shuts Me Down Once more
By Tony Heller, His Weblog, Feb 19, 2021
https://realclimatescience.com/2021/02/youtube-shuts-me-down-again/
Suppressing Scientific Inquiry
Who will Ridd us?
By John Robson, Local weather Dialogue Nexus, Feb 17, 2021
Difficult the Orthodoxy — NIPCC
Local weather Change Reconsidered II: Bodily Science
Idso, Carter, and Singer, Lead Authors/Editors, Nongovernmental Worldwide Panel on Local weather Change (NIPCC), 2013
Abstract: https://www.heartland.org/_template-assets/paperwork/CCR/CCR-II/Abstract-for-Policymakers.pdf
Local weather Change Reconsidered II: Organic Impacts
Idso, Idso, Carter, and Singer, Lead Authors/Editors, Nongovernmental Worldwide Panel on Local weather Change (NIPCC), 2014
Abstract: https://www.heartland.org/media-library/pdfs/CCR-IIb/Abstract-for-Policymakers.pdf
Local weather Change Reconsidered II: Fossil Fuels
By A number of Authors, Bezdek, Idso, Legates, and Singer eds., Nongovernmental Worldwide Panel on Local weather Change, April 2019
Obtain with no cost:
Why Scientists Disagree About International Warming
The NIPCC Report on the Scientific Consensus
By Craig D. Idso, Robert M. Carter, and S. Fred Singer, Nongovernmental Worldwide Panel on Local weather Change (NIPCC), Nov 23, 2015
Obtain with no cost:
https://www.heartland.org/policy-documents/why-scientists-disagree-about-global-warming
Nature, Not Human Exercise, Guidelines the Local weather
S. Fred Singer, Editor, NIPCC, 2008
International Sea-Stage Rise: An Analysis of the Knowledge
By Craig D. Idso, David Legates, and S. Fred Singer, Heartland Coverage Temporary, Might 20, 2019
Difficult the Orthodoxy
The New Darkish Age: The self-destruction of an power superpower
Editorial, WSJ, Through GWPF, Feb 17, 2021
A deep inexperienced freeze: An existential risk to America’s future
Editorial, WSJ, Through GWPF, Feb 16, 2021
Richard Betts’ Pseudo Science
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 17, 2021
Video by Ben Pile
Is the Texas Chilly Wave Induced By International Warming?
By Cliff Mass, Climate Weblog, Feb 17, 2021
https://cliffmass.blogspot.com/search?updated-max=2021-02-18T14:30:00-08:00&max-results=2
Evaluation of local weather change threat to the insurance coverage sector
By Judith Curry. Local weather And so on. Feb 15, 2021
“The eventualities for local weather change out to 2050 introduced by AIR are primarily based on an implausible emissions state of affairs that produces an implausible quantity of warming by 2050. Even when this massive quantity of warming is accepted as believable, the state of affairs for considerably elevated numbers of main hurricane landfalls impacting the U.S. is judged to be not possible if not borderline implausible.”
[SEPP Comment: Curry recognizes that the AIR models for catastrophic risk are beyond help despite the claim of embodying the latest science.]
Is Local weather Change Making Texas Winters Colder?
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 18, 2021
“After all, I have to make my typical caveat; these [NOAA] graphs are derived from closely adjusted and homogenized temperature knowledge.
“Are Texas winters getting colder, or are the NOAA figures right?”
Local weather: The Proof-Free Science
By Tony Heller, His Weblog, Feb 19, 2021
https://realclimatescience.com/2021/02/climate-the-evidence-free-science/
Defending the Orthodoxy – Bandwagon Science
When Sensible Folks Get the Local weather Crazies
By Michael Kile, Quadrant, Jan 20, 2021
Research reveal world ice soften estimates have been conservative
By Evan Lim, Earth Institute at Columbia College, Feb 18, 2021 [H/t Bernie Kepshire]
https://phys.org/information/2021-02-reveal-global-ice.html
[SEPP Comment: Conservative exaggeration rather than liberal exaggeration?]
Questioning the Orthodoxy
Texas and The Looming Vitality Disaster
By Donn Dears, Energy For USA, Feb 17, 2021
Hyperlink to video.
Texas Electrical energy Disaster
By Alex Epstein, Vitality Speaking Factors, Accessed Feb 17, 2021 [H/t William Readdy]
https://energytalkingpoints.com/texas-electricity-crisis/
Distorting the Levelized Value of Electrical energy
By Donn Dears, Energy For USA, Feb 16, 2021
[SEPP Comment: Exposing how the International Energy Agency (IEA) and the Nuclear Energy Agency (NEA) rig the numbers to make wind and solar appear low cost.]
Will Local weather Alarm Lastly Finish When the World Doesn’t?
By Larry Bell, Newsmax, Feb 16, 2021
https://www.newsmax.com/larrybell/edenhofer-frontline-ipcc-pbs/2021/02/15/id/1010026/
“Moon Pictures” Gained’t Remedy the Local weather Disaster
By David Whitehouse, Actual Clear Vitality, Feb 17, 2021
https://www.realclearenergy.org/articles/2021/02/16/moon_shots_wont_solve_the_climate_crisis_660584.html
Extra Proof Surfaces That Fires Are Far Much less Widespread In the present day Than In The Previous
By Kenneth Richard, No Methods Zone, Feb 18, 2021
Change in US Administrations
Biden’s Economic system Will Be a Practice Wreck
Inexperienced insurance policies threat the return of inflation.
By Rupert Darwall, Actual Clear Vitality, Feb 17, 2021
https://www.realclearenergy.org/articles/2021/02/17/bidens_economy_will_be_a_train_wreck_660695.html
“Kerry and former EPA Administrator and now White Home Nationwide Local weather Advisor Gina McCarthy have been speaking in regards to the local weather change govt order that Biden had simply signed. ‘We face a local weather disaster that threatens our individuals and communities, public well being and financial system, and, starkly, our capacity to dwell on planet Earth,’ the chief order proclaimed. Its objective is to make combating local weather change the organizing precept of the Biden administration. ‘Local weather change is essentially the most vital public well being problem of our time,’ McCarthy improbably claimed. Chopping carbon-dioxide emissions will cut back childhood bronchial asthma, Kerry prompt. ‘High quality of life will likely be higher when Gina has put her crew collectively that produces decisions for us which might be more healthy, much less most cancers, cleaner air,’ he added.”
Biden’s Drilling Ban Devastates New Mexico Whereas Boosting America’s Opponents
By Kevin Mooney, Actual Clear Vitality, Feb 17, 2021
https://www.realclearenergy.org/articles/2021/02/17/bidens_drilling_ban_devastates_new_mexico_while_boosting_americas_competitors_660694.html
White Home rescinds Trump proposal to restrict greenhouse gasoline consideration in infrastructure choices
By Rachel Frazin, The Hill, Feb 18, 2021
https://thehill.com/coverage/energy-environment/539397-white-house-rescinds-trump-proposal-aiming-to-limit-greenhouse-gas
Issues within the Orthodoxy
EU falling quick on 2030 local weather goal
By Workers, Bloomberg, Through GWPF, Feb 18, 2021
Un-Greening: Mexico offers up on renewables, revives coal trade
By Jo Nova, Her Weblog, Feb 16, 2021
Germany Determined For Coal Energy, As Wind & Photo voltaic Energy Fail
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 13, 2021
Looking for a Widespread Floor
Assigning Blame for the Blackouts in Texas
By Planning Engineer, Local weather And so on. Feb 18, 2021
Hyperlink to report: Why doesn’t Texas Have a Capability Market
By Workers, The Present, Apr 10, 20219
Why I Am a Local weather Realist
By Vijay Jayaraj, WUWT, Feb 18, 2021
Science, Coverage, and Proof
Local weather Information or Leaps of Religion? Governments Can’t Inform the Distinction
We now have no laborious proof of a disaster. Solely skilled opinion and finest estimates.
By Donna Laframboise, Massive Image Information, Feb 17, 2021
The progress of the COVID-19 epidemic in Sweden: an replace
By Nic Lewis, Local weather And so on. Feb 18, 2021
[SEPP Comment: Also compares “excess deaths” in Sweden with England.]
Evaluate of Current Scientific Articles by CO2 Science
Physiological Buffering by a Marine Macroalgae Ameliorates Ocean Acidification and Warming Results on a Giant Foraminifer
Doo, S.S., Leplastrier, A., Graba-Landry, A., Harianto, J., Coleman, R.A. and Byrne, M. 2020. Amelioration of ocean acidification and warming results by physiological buffering of a macroalgae. Ecology and Evolution, DOI: 10.1002/ece3.6552. Feb 17, 2021
http://www.co2science.org/articles/V24/feb/a8.php
“Consequently, on condition that the complete future outlook of this foraminifer modified from dangerous to good when permitting for its interplay with an ecologically-relevant algal species, Doo et al. name for additional investigations into ‘species interactions, significantly multispecies symbioses that present organic buffering companies’ as scientists try and discern the true destiny of marine organisms in response to projected adjustments in ocean warming and acidification.”
CO2-induced Reductions in N2O emissions in a Subtropical Rice Discipline
Yao, Z., Wang, R., Zheng, X., Mei, B., Zhoe, Z., Xie, B., Dong, H., Liu, C., Han, S., Xu, Z., Butterbach-Bahl, Ok. and Zhu, J. 2020. Elevated atmospheric CO2 reduces yield-scaled N2O fluxes from subtropical rice techniques: Six site-years area experiments. International Change Biology 27: 327-339. Feb 15, 2021
http://www.co2science.org/articles/V24/feb/a7.php
A Photo voltaic-Local weather Hyperlink in Northern Fennoscandia
Ogurtsov, M., Veretenenko, S.V., Helama, S., Jalkanen, R. and Lindholm, M. 2020. Assessing the alerts of the Hale photo voltaic cycle in temperature proxy data from Northern Fennoscandia. Advances in Area Analysis 66: 2113-2121. Feb 12, 2021
http://www.co2science.org/articles/V24/feb/a6.php
“However, correlation doesn’t show causation. There have to be a bodily mechanism explaining the solar-driven temperature adjustments. And though discerning that mechanism (or mechanisms) was past the scope of their evaluation, Ogurtsov et al. opine ‘galactic cosmic ray flux appears like essentially the most most likely bodily agent,’ offering a number of explanations and citations from the literature to again up their concept.”
Fashions v. Observations
Richard’s X Field or Actual World Knowledge?
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 17, 2021
“I started by asking why we want this new local weather attribution science?
“The reply is after all apparent. There’s a must “blame” issues on local weather change. It’s nothing to do with science, and every little thing to do with politics.”
Junk Grade Fashions: Even Brief-Time period Local weather And Climate Modelers Get It All Mistaken
By P Gosselin, No Methods Zone, Feb 19, 2021
[SEPP Comment: Great photo of the US temperature outlook for January to March 2021 by the Weather Channel.]
Measurement Points — Floor
Scientists say (Eight)
By John Robson, Local weather Dialogue Nexus, Feb 17, 2021
Altering Climate
January Imply Temps In Northern Europe Stall, High Local weather Scientist Concedes: Chilly Waves “Extra Frequent” Forward
By P Gosselin and Kirye, No Methods Zone Feb 18, 2021
So about that storm
By John Robson, Local weather Dialogue Nexus, Feb 17, 2021
Altering Local weather
Local weather change killed off mammoths, sloths, megafauna
By Brooks Hays, Washington DC (UPI), Feb 16, 2021
https://www.spacedaily.com/studies/Climate_change_killed_off_mammoths_sloths_megafauna_999.html
Hyperlink to paper: Local weather change, not human inhabitants progress, correlates with Late Quaternary megafauna declines in North America
By Mathew Stewart, W.C. Carleton & H. Groucutt, Nature Communications, Feb 16, 2021
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-21201-Eight
[SEPP Comment: Uses “a new Bayesian regression technique.”]
Altering Seas
Billionaire Sea Stage Hype
By Willis Eschenbach, WUWT, Feb 16, 2021
Altering Cryosphere – Land / Sea Ice
Southeast Greenland Sea Floor Temperature 1° – 2°C Hotter In 1940 Than In the present day, New Research Present
By P Gosselin. No Methods Zone, Feb 14, 2021
Hyperlink to paper: Sea Floor Temperature Variability on the SE‐Greenland Shelf (1796–2013 CE) and Its Affect on Thrym Glacier in Nørre Skjoldungesund
By David Wangner, et al. Paleoceanography and Paleoclimatology, Dec 5, 2019
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2019PA003692
Truth: polar bears are thriving regardless of sea ice loss in response to the scientific literature
By Susan Crockford, Polar Bear Science, Feb 19, 2021
How icebergs actually soften – and what this might imply for local weather change
By Workers Writers, Sydney, Australia (SPX), Feb 17, 2021
https://www.spacedaily.com/studies/How_icebergs_really_melt___and_what_this_could_mean_for_climate_change_999.html
Hyperlink to paper: Facet ratio impacts iceberg melting
By Eric W. Hester, et al. Bodily Evaluate, Fluids, Feb 12, 2021
https://journals.aps.org/prfluids/summary/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.6.023802
Geologists uncover unfamiliar beings dwelling deep beneath Antarctic ice shelf
By Brooks Hays, Washington DC (UPI), Feb 15, 2021
https://www.spacedaily.com/studies/Geologists_discover_strange_creatures_living_deep_beneath_Antarctic_ice_shelf_999.html
Agriculture Points & Worry of Famine
Corn belt farmland has misplaced a 3rd of its carbon-rich soil
By Workers Writers, Amherst MA (SPX), Feb 16, 2021
https://www.seeddaily.com/studies/Corn_belt_farmland_has_lost_a_third_of_its_carbon_rich_soil_999.html
The extent of soil loss throughout the US Corn Belt
By Evan A. Thaler, Isaac J. Larsen, and Qian Yu, PNAS, Dec 20, 2019
https://www.pnas.org/content material/118/Eight/e1922375118
[SEPP Comment: Since when, 1850? The article and abstract ignore dates. The US Department of Agriculture has long promoted contour tilling to reduce erosion.]
Decreasing Requirements
Factchecking BBC’s Factcheck
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 18, 2021
Speaking Higher to the Public – Exaggerate, or be Obscure?
Declare: Coal, Gasoline and Nuclear Vegetation are Scuffling with the Warmth of International Warming
By Eric Worrall, WUWT, Feb 16, 2021
Hyperlink to paper: Thermal energy technology is deprived in a warming world
By Ethan D Coffel and Justin S Mankin, Environmental Analysis Letters, Feb 9, 2021
https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/abd4a8
From the summary: “Thermal energy vegetation use fossil fuels or nuclear materials to generate many of the world’s electrical energy. On scorching days, when electrical energy demand peaks, the ambient air and water used to chill these vegetation can develop into too heat, forcing operators to curtail electrical energy output.”
[SEPP Comment: The difference between temperatures is important.]
The place’d my ice go?
By John Robson, Local weather Dialogue Nexus, Feb 17, 2021
Speaking Higher to the Public – Make issues up.
WHO and the “Local weather Emergency”
By Willis Eschenbach, WUWT, Feb 15, 2021
[SEPP Comment: WHO’s estimates of causes of death in 2020 are contradict the claim of “climate emergency.”]
The place are the boiling hurricanes of tomorrow?
By John Robson, Local weather Dialogue Nexus, Feb 17, 2021
BBC Replay Climate Catastrophe Losses Con Trick
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 19, 2021
Internet zero web trillions
By John Robson, Local weather Dialogue Nexus, Feb 17, 2021
“Certainly, world inexperienced finance celebrity Mark Carney, as soon as a humble central financial institution president, now says that as local weather change will kill as many individuals as COVID yearly from mid-century on, ‘The dimensions of funding in power, sustainable power and sustainable infrastructure must double. Yearly, for the course of the following three a long time, $three.5 trillion (£2.5tn) a yr, for 30 years. It is a gigantic funding alternative., Properly, alternative is one phrase. Black gap is one other.” [Boldface added]
Speaking Higher to the Public – Go Private.
Don’t Settle for 100% Of The Local weather Change Story And You Get Labeled A Racist
By Mike Shedlock, MishTalk, Through, Tyler Durden, Zero Hedge, Feb 18, 2021
https://www.zerohedge.com/political/dont-accept-100-climate-change-story-and-you-get-labeled-racist
Speaking Higher to the Public – Use Propaganda on Youngsters
Creepy Youngsters’s Local weather Video: What if People Disappeared?
By Eric Worrall, WUWT, Feb 14, 2021
The Impression of Poisonous Propaganda on America’s Youngsters
By Larry Bell, America Out Loud, Feb 15, 2021
Questioning European Inexperienced
Boris Johnson’s Internet Zero dilemma: Financial restoration or local weather cap on holidays overseas
By Workers, The Sunday Instances, Through GWPF, Feb 14, 2021
Fears over China’s Muslim pressured labour loom over EU solar energy
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 14, 2021
Questioning Inexperienced Elsewhere
Why Some Environmentalists Don’t Admire Prosperity
Folks having fun with the very best environmental high quality and the very best requirements of dwelling are additionally disproportionately extra prone to be pessimistic.
By Marian L. Tupy, Human Progress, Sep 24, 2019 [H/t William Readdy]
The Inexperienced Bubble
By Andrew Stuttaford, Nationwide Evaluate, Capital Issues, Feb 13, 2021
https://www.nationalreview.com/2021/02/the-green-bubble/
The vice that’s virtue-signaling
By Christopher Monckton of Brenchley, WUWT, Feb 16, 2021
Subsidies and Mandates Without end
Wind Subsidies Assist Freeze Texans
By Invoice Peacock, Grasp Useful resource, Feb 18, 2021
“In the course of the vital four-hour interval from 10 p.m. to 2 a.m. when ERCOT was pressured to start rolling blackouts, precise wind output averaged lower than 5% of the ERCOT load. This was down from about 58% the week earlier than. It could be laborious to overstate the injury brought on by wind’s unreliability Monday evening—or the hurt its intermittency causes frequently.”
“The place was photo voltaic, essentially the most quickly rising new power supply in Texas, Monday evening? The place photo voltaic is each evening—off the grid, for the easy purpose that the solar was not shining. Some would possibly declare that is no massive deal as a result of photo voltaic will not be designed to generate electrical energy at evening. Precisely. Its major design function additionally proved to be its primary design flaw Monday evening.”
Owners Fleeced By Renewable Subsidies
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 15, 2021
Vitality Points – Non-US
UK local weather insurance policies are guilty for making gasoline poverty worse
By John Constable, GWPF, Feb 15, 2021
Why Warmth Pumps Will Increase Your Vitality Payments
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb three, 2021
GWPF accuses Authorities of driving up electrical energy costs and power poverty
Press Launch, GWPF, Feb 15, 2021
‘Low cost’ offshore wind energy claims are false, knowledge exhibits
Press Launch, International Warming Coverage Basis, Feb 19, 2021
Hyperlink to report: Offshore wind price predictions and the price of outcomes (pdf)
By Andrew Montford, GWPF, February 2021
Declare: New Zealand Economic system will Need to Restructure Round a Restricted Renewable Vitality Provide
By Eric Worrall, WUWT, Feb 18, 2021
Gasoline boss warns of upper payments to pay for greener power
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 15, 2021
Vitality Points — US
This Blizzard Exposes The Perils Of Trying To ‘Electrify Every thing’
By Robert Bryce, Forbes, Feb 15, 2021
https://www.forbes.com/websites/robertbryce/2021/02/15/this-blizzard-exposes-the-perils-of-attempting-to-electrify-everything/?sh=7d91b3d97e15
Environmentalists Need Renewable Vitality, However Not Energy Traces
The one factor that almost all environmental teams just like the NRDC and Sierra Membership do is complain, file lawsuits, and block issues. They’re by no means a part of any answer.
By Alex Berezow, ACSH, Feb 12, 2021
https://www.acsh.org/information/2021/02/12/environmentalists-want-renewable-energy-not-power-lines-15341
Hyperlink to report present energy traces: Electrical energy Distribution System Baseline Report
By WM Warwick, et al. Battelle Memorial Institute, for DOE, July 2016
Hyperlink to interim report energy line want: Internet-Zero America: Potential Pathways, Infrastructure, and Impacts
By Eric Larson, et al, Princeton Univ. Dec 16, 2020 [Forward by John Holdren]
https://environmenthalfcentury.princeton.edu/websites/g/recordsdata/toruqf331/recordsdata/2020-12/Princeton_NZA_Interim_Report_15_Dec_2020_FINAL.pdf?fbclid=IwAR3HQOmJlw6YyoCf_Zp_2V0UXSGy35weqWsItkGf57xTkj4mvqHbNhcN2pE
Gasoline Furnaces vs. DOE’s EERE (Trump trumps Obama, however Biden is Subsequent)
By Robert Bradley Jr., Grasp Useful resource, Feb 11, 2021
Vitality Points — Texas
Texas spins into the wind GWPF
Editorial, Wall Road Journal, Through GWPF, Feb 18, 2021
“Between 12 a.m. on Feb. Eight and Feb. 16, wind energy plunged 93% whereas coal elevated 47% and gasoline 450%, in response to the EIA. But the renewable trade and its media mouthpieces are tarring gasoline, coal and nuclear as a result of they didn’t function at 100% of their anticipated potential through the Arctic blast regardless that wind generators failed almost 100%.”
The Narrative is Overshadowing Reality within the Texas Vitality Disaster
By Erick-Woods Erickson, His Weblog, Feb 17, 2021
https://ewerickson.substack.com/p/the-narrative-is-overshadowing-truth
“Texas and different states haven’t any incentive to construct baseload capability as a result of federal subsidies for renewables distort the market. Likewise, sustaining and weatherizing these baseload techniques is economically disincentivized by those self same federal subsidies. Moreover, most renewal power techniques haven’t any obligations to contribute to upkeep of the prevailing energy grid or ramp up capability to that grid.”
The Day After Tomorrow: Renewables Fail Version
By David Middleton, WUWT, Feb 17, 2021
Texas Wind Energy Failure Continues, Most of State Experiencing Outages
By Anthony Watts, Heartland Each day, Feb 16, 2021
https://heartlanddailynews.com/2021/02/texas-wind-power-failure-continues-most-of-state-experiencing-outages/
Texas’ energy grid crumples underneath the chilly
Competitors for pure gasoline and frozen wind generators are solely among the issues.
By John Timmer, ARS Technicana, Feb 15, 2021 [H/t William Readdy]
https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/02/texas-power-grid-crumples-under-the-cold/
Texas frozen wind energy – outages ensue, electrical energy now at unparalleled $9000 per megawatt-hour
By Anthony Watts, WUWT, Feb 15, 2021
Texas Energy Freeze-Down Demonstrates Political Man-Made Local weather Disaster
By Larry Bell, Newsmax, Feb 19, 2021
https://www.newsmax.com/larrybell/texas-deep-freeze-windmills-energy/2021/02/19/id/1010709/
“The assured output of wind + solar = zero.”
Texas: Time To Get Rid Of This Ridiculous Wind Energy
By Francis Menton, Manhattan Contrarian, Feb 17, 2021
https://www.manhattancontrarian.com/weblog/2021-2-17-texas-time-to-get-rid-of-this-ridiculous-wind-power
Think about Texas With out Fossil Fuels
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 17, 2021
“Arctic air freezes Permian shale fields”… Faux information?
Reporting from Ice Station Dallas
By David Middleton, WUWT, Feb 28, 2021
Frozen wind generators hamper Texas energy output, state’s electrical grid operator says
By Brandon Mulder, Austin American-Statesman, Feb 14, 2021
https://www.statesman.com/story/information/2021/02/14/historic-winter-storm-freezes-texas-wind-turbines-hampering-electric-generation/4483230001/
Outages or managed blackouts slightly than complete blackout. Grid operators made sensible choices.
Frozen Wind Farms Are Only a Small Piece of Texas’s Energy Woes
By Will Wade, Naureen Malik, and Brian Eckhouse, Bloomberg Inexperienced, Feb 15, 2021 [H/t Jim Hollingsworth]
https://www.bloomberg.com/information/articles/2021-02-16/frozen-wind-farms-were-just-a-small-piece-of-texas-s-power-woes
Hi there Clear Vitality Advocates, What Do We Do When The Wind Generators Are All Frozen?
By Mike Shedlock, by way of Zero Hedge, Feb 16, 2021 [H/t Bernie Kepshire]
https://www.zerohedge.com/power/hello-clean-energy-advocates-what-do-we-do-when-wind-turbines-are-all-frozen
Midwest Have No Surplus Energy For Texas
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 18, 2021
Revenue warning as Texas freeze halts wind farms
By Workers, Reuters, Through GWPF, Feb 19, 2021
Washington’s Management of Vitality
President’s Day: Finest and Worst, Vitality-wise
By Robert Bradley Jr., Grasp Useful resource, Feb 15, 2021
Nuclear Vitality and Fears
Germany involved about Poland’s nuclear power plans
The Polish authorities desires to start out producing nuclear power in 2033 and has agreed to offers with the US and France. However Germany is more and more alarmed by its neighbor’s power plans.
By Monika Sieradzka, DW, Feb 17, 2021
https://www.dw.com/en/germany-concerned-about-polands-nuclear-energy-plans/a-56603782
Various, Inexperienced (“Clear”) Photo voltaic and Wind
Texas Windpower: Will Unfavorable Pricing Blow Out the Lights? (PTC vs. dependable new capability)
By Josiah Neeley, Grasp Useful resource, Feb 17, 2021
“Ed. notice: This publish, initially revealed at MasterResource in November 2012, is reposted verbatim for its relevancy now that wind energy has two seasons of questionable output: freezing winter in addition to stagnant summer season. (Two updates are offered in brackets on the finish of the article.) The ‘seen’ in the present day is the frozen wind turbine; the ‘unseen’ is the gist of the publish under: phantom fossil-fired technology capability given the ruined economics from unfair competitors.”
World’s ‘photo voltaic and wind capital’ freezing resulting from snow ‘blanketing tens of millions’ of photo voltaic panels
By Workers, Sky Information Australia, Feb 14, 2021
https://www.msn.com/en-au/information/different/worlds-solar-and-wind-capital-freezing-due-to-snow-blanketing-millions-of-solar-panels/ar-BB1dF9Dp?ocid=sl
We now have been staggeringly blind to China’s uncommon earth dominance
By Paul Homewood, Not a Lot of Folks Know That, Feb 18, 2021
Coal rescues Germany from its renewable power folly
By Workers, Institute for Vitality Analysis, Through GWPF, Feb 17, 2021
Opponents of NJ offshore wind venture fear generators will have an effect on views, fishing, and tourism
By Jason Nark, Phys.org, Feb 16, 2021 [H/t Bernie Kepshire]
https://phys.org/information/2021-02-opponents-nj-offshore-turbines-affect.html
[SEPP Comment: Also, they won’t work during a Bermuda High in August when electricity demand is the greatest.]
Various, Inexperienced (“Clear”) Automobiles
Weakest hyperlink to EV progress is the fabric provide chain
There is probably not sufficient minerals and metals on the planet to attain the deliberate EV progress
By Ronald Stein, WUWT, Feb 15, 2021
Texas Freeze Raises Value Of Charging A Tesla To $900
By Charles Kennedy, Oil Worth.com, Feb 16, 2021
https://oilprice.com/Vitality/Vitality-Common/Texas-Freeze-Raises-Value-Of-Charging-A-Tesla-To-900.html
Inexperienced Folly: Berlin’s Metropolis E-Buses Depart Passengers Out In The Chilly…Diesel Buses To The Rescue.
Germany’s capital Berlin was pressured to switch a few of its electrical buses with diesel buses resulting from vary issues related to the chilly climate.
By P Gosselin, No Methods Zone, Feb 17, 2021
“When requested by WELT, Nelken [Spokeswoman for the bus company] additionally emphasised that the buses have been usually not utterly out of service, however solely needed to return to the depot (and to the charging) sooner than typical.”
Carbon Schemes
Why Does CCS Matter?
By Jude Clemente, Rigzone, Feb 10, 2021
https://www.rigzone.com/information/why_does_ccs_matter-10-feb-2021-164585-article/
[SEPP Comment: The IEA study used is more imaginary line drawing than hard evidence. Other than for enhanced oil or natural gas recovery, no hard evidence of actual costs.]
Different Scientific Information
NASA desires to fly a helicopter on Mars for the primary time
By AFP Workers Writers, Washington (AFP), Feb 16, 2021
https://www.marsdaily.com/studies/NASA_wants_to_fly_a_helicopter_on_Mars_for_the_first_time_999.html
“Transported aboard the Mars 2020 spacecraft that arrives on the Pink Planet on Thursday, the small Ingenuity helicopter can have a number of challenges to beat — the most important being the rarefied Martian environment, which is only one p.c the density of Earth’s.”
Scientists develop cyanobacteria underneath Mars-like circumstances
By Brooks Hays, Washington DC (UPI), Feb 17, 2021
https://www.marsdaily.com/studies/Scientists_grow_cyanobacteria_under_Mars_like_conditions_999.html
Hyperlink to paper: A Low-Strain, N2/CO2 Environment Is Appropriate for Cyanobacterium-Primarily based Life-Help Methods on Mars
By Cyprien Verseux, et al. Frontiers in Microbiology, Feb 16, 2021
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmicb.2021.611798/full
Different Information that Might Be of Curiosity
The UK Vitality Shortages of Winter 1946–47 (deliberate chaos w/o costs and earnings)
By Robert Bradley Jr., Grasp Useful resource, Feb 16, 2021
Drop in CO2 helped dinosaurs migrate from South America to Greenland
By Brook Hays, Washington DC (UPI) Feb 15, 2021
https://www.spacedaily.com/studies/Drop_in_CO2_helped_dinosaurs_migrate_from_South_America_to_Greenland_999.html
[SEPP Comment: Unable to link to paper on the long journey across Pangea.]
Soiled Electrical energy, however Not the Sort You Assume
By Aaron Larson, Energy Magazine, Feb 28, 2021
[SEPP Comment: Save us from “electricity pollution!”]
BELOW THE BOTTOM LINE
three. 2.. 1… Declare: Extreme Winter Storms Attributable to International Warming
By Eric Worrall, WUWT, Feb 17, 2021
Deepwater Horizon spill has long-term results on dolphins’ immune techniques
By Brooks Hays, Washington DC (UPI), Feb 18, 2021
https://www.terradaily.com/studies/Deepwater_Horizon_spill_has_long-term_effects_on_dolphins_immune_systems_999.html
“Scientists have been capable of replicate the immunological results of oil publicity within the lab utilizing mice fashions.”
[SEPP Comment: How close is a mouse model to a real dolphin?]
NATO Chief wonders about Photo voltaic Powered Battle Tanks
By Jo Nova, Her Weblog, Feb 14, 2021
ARTICLES
Science Wants Criticism, Not Cheerleading
‘Once we decrease our requirements to faux we all know what we don’t know, we diminish the work and misinform society,’ says Prof. John Staddon.
By J. Peder Zane. WSJ, Feb 19, 2021
https://www.wsj.com/articles/science-needs-criticism-not-cheerleading-11613772365?mod=hp_opin_pos_2
TWTW Abstract: The columnist writes:
“When Prof. John Staddon learn the ‘Assertion to the Group Concerning Anti-Racism’ despatched out by Duke College’s president this summer season, he was alarmed. The president, Vincent Worth, promised to require ‘anti-racism and anti-bias coaching for each member of our school, pupil physique, and employees.’ To Mr. Staddon, that sounded extra like indoctrination than educational inquiry. He responded in an open letter.
“Mr. Worth declared: ‘I can’t as a white individual start to totally perceive the every day concern and ache and oppression that’s endemic to the Black expertise.’ Mr. Staddon’s rejoinder: ‘Your reassurance is ok as an expression of empathy. I daresay you’re feeling higher, and presumably your African American viewers does as properly. However emotions differ: Except the dialogue may be moved from emotions to info, no concord is feasible. Empathy, guilt, and good intentions are a dodgy foundation for sweeping resolutions.’
“Mr. Worth affirmed that the ‘laborious work earlier than us’ requires the neighborhood to ‘take transformative motion now towards eliminating the techniques of racism and inequality. . . . That begins with a private transformation and . . . should finish in institutional transformation.’ Mr. Staddon countered that ‘this phrasing will strike many as extra like psychotherapy or a name to non secular conversion than a coverage prescription. What are these ‘techniques of racism and inequality?’ How have they affected Duke and the way is Duke concerned in them? Or are they societal issues and thus the duty not of a college however of presidency, the church, and civil society?’
“This isn’t the primary time Mr. Staddon, 83, a tall, English-born American, has challenged the dogma of his friends. A professor of psychology, neuroscience and biology, he’s one thing of a contemporary Cassandra, warning for greater than three a long time of the corruption of academia by political activists. As America turns into woke, his scholarly critiques learn like prophecy.
“However Staddon is a scientist, not a political firebrand. He doesn’t commerce barbs over opinions however challenges his colleagues to reply the query that has lengthy been the muse of Western thought and science: How have you learnt what you understand?
“In an interview at his Durham house, Mr. Staddon remembers an episode that mirrored this downside. An nameless reviewer of his 2017 guide, ‘Scientific Methodology’—a broad protection of the method of verification—scolded him for airing the issues of latest science. ‘My critic felt that science is underneath assault now, so anybody who writes about it for a common viewers ought to do his finest to defend it,’ Mr. Staddon remembers. ‘Science, after all, ought to want no protection in a society whose existence is determined by it. However when science will not be in a wholesome state, it wants not cheerleading however understanding and enchancment. Science is strengthened not by reward however by criticism.’
“Whereas Mr. Staddon has addressed points within the laborious sciences, he’s extra involved with ‘festering’ issues within the social sciences, ‘the place weak science competes with activist political tendencies across the fraught problems with race, class and gender.’ In a forthcoming guide, ‘Truth vs. Ardour: Science within the Age of Unreason,’ he writes that ‘many social scientists have problem separating info from religion, actuality from the best way they want issues to be. Many analysis subjects have develop into taboo which, in flip, signifies that coverage makers are making choices primarily based extra on ideologically-driven political strain than scientific truth.’”
The writer goes by a protracted dialogue of racial points and social sciences earlier than concluding:
“These distinctions could strike some as educational. Mr. Staddon says they’re, in the very best sense of the phrase: ‘Science is the seek for fact, which is usually elusive. Once we decrease our requirements to faux we all know what we don’t know, we diminish the work and misinform society.’”[Boldface added]
Associated
