Do-it-yourself Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe

This web site could comprise affiliate hyperlinks and promoting in order that we will present recipes to you. Learn my privateness coverage.

This do-it-yourself ice cream sandwich recipe is the last word summer season deal with. They’re made along with your favourite ice cream that’s sandwiched between a brownie-like crust that stays mushy even when frozen. Make an enormous batch and revel in all of them summer season lengthy!

To take these to the following stage, attempt making them with The Finest Strawberry Ice Cream, No Churn Brownie Batter Ice Cream, or enjoyable and straightforward Ice Cream in a Bag.

homemade ice cream sandwich bars on a serving plate.

Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe

There’s nothing like biting into an ice cream sandwich with a mushy, brownie-like crust and your favourite ice cream. That is really the perfect summertime dessert and it’s assured to carry a smile to your face. And since this recipe is remarkably simple to make, it’s a fantastic one to make with the youngsters. We have now a lot enjoyable making these every summer season and dipping the perimeters of every sandwich in mini chocolate chips, sprinkles, or chopped nuts to personalize every deal with.

When you make them, freeze them wrapped individually so you possibly can have a fast deal with everytime you get an ice cream craving.

Learn how to Make Ice Cream Sandwiches

You’ll be amazed at how simple it’s to make this recipe! See how simple it’s to make do-it-yourself ice cream sandwiches? For the complete recipe, see the recipe card under.

  1. Make a skinny brownie. This is rather like making an everyday brownie solely you bake it in a bigger pan in order that it’s fairly skinny. As soon as it’s utterly cool, take it out of the pan and minimize it in half and put one half on a some parchment paper.
  2. Select for favourite ice cream and provides it a fast whisk in a stand mixer or with elecrtic beaters. That is to ensure it’s tremendous mushy however not runny. Now pile that mushy ice cream on prime of the brownie half.
  3. Sandwich the ice cream with the opposite half of the brownie then put it into your freezer.
  4. Minimize it into smaller squares as soon as it’s utterly frozen. Don’t fear, the brownie doesn’t freeze strong so that you’ll have the ability to minimize it.
Ice cream sandwiches lined up in a row.

Suggestions for the Finest Ice Cream Sandwiches

Whereas making do-it-yourself ice cream sandwiches isn’t troublesome, comply with these few suggestions to make sure your treats prove completely!

  • Baking Sheet: Use an 18″x13″ baking sheet for the brownie – no smaller! A small pan will make a brownie that’s too thick.
  • Cool your Brownies: Be sure that the brownie is 100% cool earlier than you narrow it in half and put the ice cream on prime. A heat brownie will soften the ice cream!
  • Freezing: Don’t rush freezing the enormous ice cream sandwich. If the ice cream within the heart isn’t frozen, it can squish out while you attempt to minimize it.
  • Toppings: In case you’re including sprinkles, chopped nuts, or chocolate chips to the perimeters of your ice cream sandwiches, allow them to sit out for a couple of minutes after you narrow them so the ice cream softens sufficient for the sprinkles and so forth to stay to.
  • Take pleasure in! Don’t fret if the ice cream begins to soften or the sandwiches don’t look as good because the store-bought sort. Lick up the tasty drips and embrase the informal really feel of those completely scrumptious do-it-yourself ice cream sandwiches.

Learn how to retailer Do-it-yourself Ice Cream Sandwiches

Until you’re feeding a hungry crowd instantly, you’ll have to maintain these in your freezer. Wrap them in plastic wrap or beeswax meals wraps and retailer them collectively in a freezer bag.

How lengthy will a do-it-yourself ice cream sandwich final? If tightly wrapped, these sandwiches will maintain effectively for no less than three months.

Homemade ice cream sandwiches with sprinkles and chocolate chips.


  • Preheat your oven to 350 levels. Line a 18″x13″ pan with parchment paper, letting the ends hold over the sting of the pan.
  • In a medium-sized pot, warmth the sugars, butter, and milk till it is steaming. Take away the pot from the warmth and add the chocolate. Let the chocolate sit for three minutes then stir till it melts. As soon as the chocolate cools barely and is heat to the contact, whisk within the eggs and vanilla.
  • Add the flour, baking soda, and salt to the pot and stir simply till it’s blended in.

  • Pour the batter into the ready jelly pan, spreading the batter evenly to the perimeters – see notes. Bake for 12-15 minutes, or till it has overvalued barely and the highest seems dry. Take away the pan from the oven and gently press down on the brownie in order that it’s evenly skinny and never overvalued in locations – use a paper towel if it is too scorching in your fingers. Let the brownie cool utterly then use the parchment paper to take away it from the pan.

  • Minimize the brownie in half then lay one half on a parchment paper-lined baking sheet.

  • Use your stand mixer or electrical beaters to whip the ice cream for about 10 seconds. It must be fairly mushy and straightforward to unfold.
  • Unfold the mushy ice cream over the brownie on the baking sheet. Prime with the opposite half of the brownie then put the baking sheet into your freezer for no less than 2 hours.

  • As soon as it’s frozen, minimize it into smaller ice cream sandwiches. In case you’re utilizing sprinkles, mini chocolate chips, or nuts, dip the perimeters of the ice cream sandwiches in them then wrap every individually and retailer them in your freezer.


If the batter is difficult to unfold evenly within the pan (It is vitally thick) merely grease your fingers with some butter and gently press it down till it’s easy and even. 


Serves: 16

Energy478kcal (24%)Carbohydrates68g (23%)Proteineightg (16%)Fats21g (32%)Saturated Fats9g (45%)Polyunsaturated FatsthreegMonounsaturated Fats6gTrans Fats1gLdl cholesterol57mg (19%)Sodium299mg (12%)Potassium262mg (7%)Fiber2g (eight%)Sugar38g (42%)Vitamin A433IU (9%)Calcium119mg (12%)Iron2mg (11%)

All dietary data relies on third social gathering calculations and is just an estimate. Every recipe and dietary worth will fluctuate relying on the manufacturers you utilize, measuring strategies and portion sizes per family.

Course Dessert

Delicacies American

Key phrase do-it-yourself ice cream sandwich, ice cream sandwich

You May Also Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *